RETRACTION re Apple Factory story – This American Life

RETRACTION re Apple Factory story (This American Life, streaming + free mp3) – Worth a listen by Apple fans/foes, journalists, and aspiring journalists.

*** Before I listen to the show ***

As a journalist, I aspire to be the best I can be. No more, no less. I just hope to have the moral fiber to admit to my own past/present/future mistakes & apologize fully when the times come. At this moment, I feel the pain of Ira Glass and his colleagues.

*** After I listen to the show ***

First of all, I appreciate Ira‘s honesty and accept his apology. Secondly, after listening to Mike Daisey‘s second interview/chat with Ira re his fabricated Apple Factory story, I can no longer trust his words. Mike famously said,

“I think you can trust my word[s] in the context of the theatre.”

Huh, “in the context of the theatre”? What about things he said on TV with news media like CNBC, etc. What the heck? Was Mike serious or was he really thinking we couldn’t tell the difference between lies and truths? Under the Wikipedia journalistic scandal entry, I recognize and have followed the stories of Jayson Blair and Stephen Glass. I am wondering under what category should Mike Daisey‘s name be placed? May be under a lesson about ethics and integrity for journalists and aspiring journalists.

Update: WaPo, “Performer Mike Daisey scrubs his monologue about Apple and sticks to the facts after criticism” (emphasis added)

“Daisey portrayed his work as fact during a media blitz to promote his critically acclaimed show, and he misled dozens of news and entertainment outlets, including the popular public radio show “This American Life,” The Associated Press, The New York Times, MSNBC and HBO’s “Real Time with Bill Maher.”

But in an interview with “This American Life” host Ira Glass broadcast Friday, Daisey acknowledged that some of the claims in his show, “The Agony and the Ecstasy of Steve Jobs,” weren’t true. The show retracted its Jan. 6 episode because Glass said he couldn’t vouch for the truth of its claims.

See also,

- NYT Media Decoder, “‘This American Life’ Retracts Episode on Apple’s Suppliers in China

- This American Life retraction, “RETRACTING “MR. DAISEY AND THE APPLE FACTORY”” [HT Jason]

- New Yorker, “APPLE, CHINA, AND THE TRUTH

- Bloomberg, “Apple, Foxconn Report Retracted by ‘This American Life’

- The Daily Beast, “How Mike Daisey’s Zeal Got the Best of Him

- Wired, “Largely Unaltered Show Goes On for Fact-Challenged Apple Monologist

- Fortune, “Apple and the Daisey affair

[HT @deantak "Worth a listen: This American Life’s emotional showdown with Mike Daisey over iPad factory conditions"]

About these ads

Comments are closed.

Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 689 other followers

%d bloggers like this: